I've had quite a few emails these past few months about a nifty little plugin called Any File Lightroom Plugin. The promises of this plugin sound fabulous - "import any type of file into a Lightroom 3 catalog and manage the files just like photos..."
I should preface this post by saying a few things (disclaimers):
- I LOVE Lightroom because it is fast, quick and gets me what I need in seconds.
- I am passionate about organizing my digital files for the LAST time - that means the metadata I do write to the files stays INSIDE the files. This way problems with catalogs or files getting jumbled up and disconnected won't cause me to lose all my work.
So with that in mind, I decided to give the plugin. I recently downloaded The Daily Digi files and hadn't processed them yet. I imported the elements from one of the kits using the Any File Lightroom plugin.
The first thing that I noticed is that the import process took about four times what it usually does. However, one thing to consider is that the Any File plugin was building JPEG proxy files for each PNG files, so that is understandable. When it was finished, this is how the thumbnails looked in my catalog:
The AF overlay delineates that these files are proxy thumbnails. If you right click on the file and choose Show in Finder, you will find that the AF plugin has created proxy JPEGs right next to their PNG counterparts:
Keeping in mind my usual workflow, I gathered a bunch of supplies for a layout in my "current layout" collection in Lightroom and then opened them up in Photoshop using the Lightroom Edit In > Edit in Adobe Photoshop CS5 > Edit Original command in Lightroom. I ended up opening the JPEG proxy files in Photoshop...
Ack! I should have read the instructions beforehand. So this time let's follow the instructions from the AFP Website that say, "To open files in their default application, as configured by Windows or Mac OS, select the files and do Library > Plug-in Extras > Any File > Open (keyboard shortcut ALT+L S O on Windows)."
So I follow the instructions... and I get the spinning beach ball. I also learned that my "default application" for PNG files is Preview...
At this point I decide there has to be a better way. I change the global file association for PNG files on my Mac by right clicking on the file and choosing Get Info.
In the Get Info I scroll down to the "Open With" pane and use the drop down menu to select Photoshop:
That works great for this file, but I want this to be the case with ALL my PNG files:
Clicking the magical "Change All" button does that! Now when I open the PNG files with the plugin, I get this in my chosen PNG program, Photoshop:
Now, we are good to go... Technically the plugin is allowing me to write metadata to the JPEG proxy file. I can also use the plugin to open up my PNG files in Photoshop. I should be happy, right? I'm not.
If the goal is to get organized for the last time, you need to remember the PRENUP. If you lost Lightroom or your catalog tomorrow, and your files got jumbled from here to Hades, what happens then? You spend hours trying to reconnect everything together. Not fun.
Also, once you bring in files through Any File, you can't ever move them like you do regular files in Lightroom. You have to write metadata to files, remove them from your Lightroom catalog, then move them in Windows Explorer or Mac Finder and then reimport them. It can be done, but it takes a lot of extra time.
The way Any File works is by adding extra JPEG files of your PNG images and then writing metadata to the proxy files. In my opinion, you might as well save yourself the time and just convert to TIF and TRULY IMPORT your files into your organization software.
Even for those who want to use Lightroom to organize and like opening images up as Smart Objects it still makes sense to convert to TIF, import to Lightroom, add your keywords, and then opening files with the following steps: Right-click to choose SHOW IN FINDER - then drag your files to Photoshop.
The goal is to organize your files for the LAST TIME. It is really hard to do that without writing metadata to your files. You need a file format with the closets to store metadata, a program that truly writes to the files and a backup system off site and on-site that protects those files.
Quite honestly, I can't see using this plugin long term. I think it is great for the casual organizer that doesn't care if they have to start over from scratch if they lose their catalog, but for those who truly want a long term solution, I'd choose another route that truly brings the original file into Lightroom.
What do you think? Are there Any File Lightroom Plugin users out there that can help me see what I'm missing?
P.S. I'm also including file association instructions for Windows users...you can use this to change associations so that with or without a plugin when you open a PNG, JPEG or other file type it automatically works with your favorite editing program. Hope you find it helpful.
Notes for Windows Users:
- Open Windows Explorer by right-clicking the Start button, and then click Explore.
- Click a folder that contains a file of the type that you want Windows to open in a program that you select.
- Right-click the file and, depending on the programs installed on your computer, complete one of the following steps:
- Click Open With to choose the program that you want.
- Point to Open With, and then click Choose Program to choose the program that you want.
- The Open With dialog box is displayed. Use one of the following methods to select the program that you want to use for this file type:
- In the Programs list, click the program that you want to use.
- Click Browse, locate and then click the program that you want to use, and then click Open.
- Click Look for the appropriate program on the Web to browse the Internet for the program that you want to use.
- Click to select the Always use the selected program to open this kind of file check box if it is not selected.
- Click OK.
Recent Comments